The Cincinnati Reds are preparing for a fresh start in the 2025 season with new manager Terry Francona, following the firing of David Bell. Although some roster changes are expected, the Reds are unlikely to make major splashes in free agency, and many familiar faces are likely to return. Here are four players who might be back next year but arguably shouldn’t:
Stuart Fairchild, Outfielder
Stuart Fairchild, who ended the 2024 season on the injured list, was a key player early on when TJ Friedl struggled with injuries. Though he performed well against left-handed pitching, his struggles against right-handers made him a liability. Fairchild’s speed and above-average defense are assets, but with no minor-league options left, the Reds may need to keep him despite having other outfield prospects who could fill his role more flexibly.
Will Benson, Outfielder
Like Fairchild, Will Benson offers speed and solid defense, but he has the advantage of having minor-league options available. His 2024 season was disappointing, marked by a high strikeout rate, contrasting with a promising 2023. While there’s a possibility he could be cut this offseason, Benson is likely to survive roster trimming due to his ability to be sent down to the minors if needed.
Lyon Richardson, Pitcher
Lyon Richardson’s roster spot isn’t immediately threatened, but if the Reds bring in new talent via trades or free agency, he could be at risk. The former second-round pick hasn’t found success in his limited major-league appearances, but given the Reds’ tendency to hold onto young pitchers, Richardson may get another chance in 2025 unless his spot is needed for a more established player.
Jeimer Candelario, Infielder
Jeimer Candelario’s future with the Reds is the most contentious issue. After signing a significant deal last offseason, his performance in 2024 fell far short of expectations. With $30 million remaining on his contract, finding a trade partner will be difficult, and releasing him outright would mean eating the rest of his salary. While the Reds have parted with expensive contracts in the past, such as Mike Moustakas, Candelario’s situation is trickier given the years left on his deal. As a result, he’s likely to stay on the roster despite his struggles.
These players may not be the ideal choices for a team looking to improve, but financial constraints and roster management realities mean they are likely to get another shot with the Reds in 2025.
Leave a Reply